In 2009, Kristine and Michael Barnett adopted a 6-year-old girl from Ukraine named Natalia Grace. She had dwarfism and was initially thought to be around 8 years old when adopted. However, soon after the adoption, the Barnetts began to suspect that Natalia was older than originally thought. Natalia displayed behaviors that seemed too mature for a young child. She had extensive knowledge of adult topics, did not want to play with typical toys for her apparent age, and showed interest in teenage activities. She also displayed inappropriate sexual behaviors.
The Barnetts took Natalia to see various medical specialists who conducted bone density tests to determine her age. The results estimated Natalia's age to be closer to 14 or older, rather than the 6-8 years initially thought. The Barnetts came to believe that Natalia had been an adult all along who was scamming adoptive families.
Legal Troubles for the Barnetts
In 2010, the Barnetts went through a legal process to change Natalia's age from 8 to 22. This allowed them to rent an apartment for Natalia rather than continue caring for her as their child.
In 2013, the Barnetts legally vacated the adoption and moved to Canada without Natalia. They believed she could care for herself as an adult. This led to child abandonment charges in 2019 when Natalia reported them to police after they returned to the U.S.
The Barnetts claimed they were victims of a fraud and that Natalia had fooled doctors as well. Prosecutors eventually dropped the charges against the Barnetts, but questions still remain about Natalia's true age and identity.
The Ongoing Mystery and Debate
Natalia Grace's case continues to be shrouded in mystery. Some key questions that remain unanswered include:
- Is Natalia Grace an adult who intentionally deceived the Barnetts and doctors? Or is she a child with a rare disorder that causes her to appear older?
- How could multiple medical experts have been so wrong about her age? Were their tests inaccurate or misinterpreted?
- If Natalia was an adult posing as a child, what was her motivation? Was she involved in criminal activity or seeking immigration status?
- Do any records of Natalia's life in Ukraine exist that could help establish her true age and identity?
There is also debate around the ethics of the Barnetts' actions:
- Should they have sought more opinions or testing on Natalia's age before changing her legal documents?
- Was it right to rent an apartment for Natalia and leave her there, even if they believed she was an adult?
- Are the Barnetts victims of an elaborate scam, or did they fail in their duty to properly care for someone they adopted as a child?
Natalia Grace's case raises many complex questions about child welfare, adoption, immigration, and medical testing. Until more definitive evidence comes to light, the curious case of Natalia Grace will likely remain unresolved. Her unique situation will continue to confound and divide observers trying to determine the truth.
Cite this Essay
To export a reference to this article please select a referencing style below