Alternation of Themes and Symbols in Fairy Tales: Analysis of Shrek

Essay grade
Good
arrow downward Read Review
Words
680 (1 page)
Downloads
33
Download for Free
Essay grade
Good
arrow downward Read Review
Alternation of Themes and Symbols in Fairy Tales: Analysis of Shrek essay
Important: This sample is for inspiration and reference only

The End of Fairy Tales? How Shrek and Friends Have Changed Children’s Stories, written by James Poniewozik, provides criticism on how children are exposed to fairy tales in today’s society and how they are not being presented in the traditional storyline. In particular, Poniewozik uses the Shrek film trilogy as a prime example that illustrates how the themes and symbols of fairy tales are alternating. He states at the beginning of the text that Shrek depicts unappealing figures such as ogres and other creatures to exhibit heroic traits, whereas characters such as a prince demonstrate negative behavior. This is unusual in original fairy tales since humans and other friendly characters were typically the protagonists while the villains tend to be vicious animals or monsters. After providing other examples of movies that capture a different perspective of fairy tales, Poniewozik discusses the underlying messages that fairy tales revolved around. He explains that what fairy tales initially focused on, such as the dangers of bad people and having obedience, is changing through films and questions the reader if there is a loss of value through this.

No time to compare samples?
Hire a Writer

✓Full confidentiality ✓No hidden charges ✓No plagiarism

The passage transitions to reflect on television shows that directly parodied fairy tale traditions. Titles, including Fractured Fairy Tales, have impacted how children perceive the messages delivered in these types of stories. Poniewozik claims people, especially young kids, are exposed and more interested in the parodies and alternations of fairy tales instead of the original stories themselves. Shrek is mentioned again, and Poniewozik argues that children in today’s world are more likely to learn “Puss in Boots” the character through the movie and not through the actual story of the cat. The passage stresses the large-scale effect of these parodies by saying, “Shrek didn’t remake fairy tales single-handed; it captured, and monetized, a long-simmering cultural trend” (394, Poniewozik). He later goes into depth with this argument, concluding that everybody, not just children, is subjected to accept parodies rather than original fairy tales. He demonstrates this by revealing how the Shrek trilogy contains comedic elements that please adults and explains how old fairy tales are simply boring to modern times. Numerous instances of how the movies relate to adult life is given by the context, “More broadly, each movie gives Shrek and Fiona an adult challenge: in the first to find love and see beyond appearances; in Shrek 2 to meet the in-laws; in Shrek the Third, to take on adult responsibility and parent-hood (Shrek has to find a new heir to the throne of Far Far Away, or he will have to succeed the king)” (395, Poniewozik).

The End of Fairy Tales? emphasizes the decisions moviemakers execute and how they structure parodies of fairy tales. Poniewozik wrestles with the legacy of Disney and elaborates more on Shrek. He admits that these parodies appeal to his own humor and why one should not ignore the themes of these parodies. According to the passage, “I feel like a traitor to my fellow parents for even saying this. These movies are made in part of me: a socially progressive, irony-friendly Gen Xer with rug rats” (396, Poniewozik). The movie, Stardust, is mentioned to support his case that parodies have many positive aspects. He claims that the astonishing settings and magical atmosphere truly makes the movie an enjoyable film.

My own view, however, is that there is a loss of value through the idea that fairy tales’ initial impression has started to fade out with the addition of movie remakes of these classic works. This has changed the view for all fairy tales as they are being changed as time goes on. Children are gaining a perspective that is enforced by movie critics and influences more so than the original author’s point of view. I always go by the saying that “The book is always better than the movie”, which applies perfectly to what Poniewozik states about the Shrek fairy tales in comparison to modern movies about the text. Without the correct perspective from the author, it forces generations to have completely different ideas about the main moral behind each individual fairy tale.

This essay is graded:
Good
minus plus
Expert Review
The essay engages with the topic of changing representations of fairy tales in modern media, particularly focusing on the impact of the Shrek film trilogy. The writer successfully summarizes and analyzes James Poniewozik's perspective on the shift in fairy tale themes and symbols. They discuss how parodies and modern adaptations are influencing children's perceptions of traditional stories. The essay effectively presents both Poniewozik's arguments and the writer's own views on the matter. The integration of quotes supports the analysis, and the personal stance adds depth. To improve further, the essay could enhance its transitions between different sections and provide more specific examples to strengthen its arguments.
minus plus
What can be improved
Introduction: Provide a concise introduction that establishes the importance of the topic of changing fairy tale representations and introduces the main arguments. Thesis Statement: Clearly state the main argument or purpose of the essay in the introduction. Analysis Depth: Go deeper into the analysis of specific examples, providing more insights into the shifts in themes and the implications for children's perceptions. Clarity in Personal View: Clarify how the writer's personal view aligns or differs from Poniewozik's arguments, offering more detailed explanations. Conclusion: Summarize the key takeaways from the essay and reiterate the impact of media adaptations on the traditional understanding of fairy tales.
You can receive your plagiarism free paper on any topic in 3 hours!

*minimum deadline

Cite this Essay

To export a reference to this article please select a referencing style below

Copy to Clipboard
Alternation of Themes and Symbols in Fairy Tales: Analysis of Shrek. (2020, December 24). WritingBros. Retrieved May 27, 2024, from https://writingbros.com/essay-examples/evolution-and-alternations-of-fairy-tales-and-the-movie-shrek/
“Alternation of Themes and Symbols in Fairy Tales: Analysis of Shrek.” WritingBros, 24 Dec. 2020, writingbros.com/essay-examples/evolution-and-alternations-of-fairy-tales-and-the-movie-shrek/
Alternation of Themes and Symbols in Fairy Tales: Analysis of Shrek. [online]. Available at: <https://writingbros.com/essay-examples/evolution-and-alternations-of-fairy-tales-and-the-movie-shrek/> [Accessed 27 May 2024].
Alternation of Themes and Symbols in Fairy Tales: Analysis of Shrek [Internet]. WritingBros. 2020 Dec 24 [cited 2024 May 27]. Available from: https://writingbros.com/essay-examples/evolution-and-alternations-of-fairy-tales-and-the-movie-shrek/
Copy to Clipboard
Alternation of Themes and Symbols in Fairy Tales: Analysis of Shrek essay

Need writing help?

You can always rely on us no matter what type of paper you need

Order My Paper

*No hidden charges

/