A Report on Structural Fire Safety: Current Issues and Solutions

Abstract

This paper aims to delve into the realm of Structural Fire Safety, exploring the existing knowledge surrounding this subject. Beyond examining current solutions to the challenges it presents, the paper will delve into intricate details available to the public while making predictions about the future development of this practice and its practitioners. It will commence its informative and summarizing segment by discussing the strategies, preventive measures, and passive elements involved in fire hazard situations. Furthermore, it will delve into the containment, active measures, and extinguishment aspects. Finally, the essay will conclude by highlighting the predictions made by renowned research organizations concerning this subject.

Introduction

Some individuals might underestimate the importance of structural fire safety in a building, assuming that materials like steel and concrete are impervious to fire. However, they fail to recognize the immense impact that fire and overheating can have on a structure. When temperatures exceed the critical thresholds of 540 degrees Celsius for steel under load and approximately 300 degrees Celsius for concrete, these materials start to lose their safety margins, leading to buckling and irreversible chemical reactions that can result in catastrophic events. The prevention of such incidents, achieved by combining various materials and measures, is known as Structural Fire Safety — a combination of two scientific divisions focused on mitigating damaging events. The first division concentrates on protection before fire or overheating, involving the use of fire-resistant coatings on building elements to delay overheating — referred to as Internal Structural Coating. However, this delay alone cannot prevent fire spread, which necessitates the second phase known as Inner and Outer Fire Safety. In essence, Structural Fire Safety encompasses practices intended to minimize the destruction caused by fire hazards, addressing blocked escape situations or conditions that may cause a fire. Such measures are incorporated during building construction or implemented in existing structures, along with educating the occupants about fire safety.

Basics of Structural Fire Safety

Strategies

In the pursuit of safety, professionals in this field rely on several key strategies:

1. Prevention: Focuses on controlling and restraining fuel sources.
2. Communication: Involves the distribution of fire systems to inform building inhabitants.
3. Escape: Inclusion of safety escape routes in case of a fire hazard.
4. Containment: Involves limiting the area affected by fire.
5. Extinguishment: Ensures the swift and effective suppression of fire hazards.

Fire Safety engineers are expected to meticulously implement and calculate these strategies to label a building as fire-safe and functional.

Prevention

Starting a fire requires only three components, ranked from most to least problematic:

1. Oxygen
2. An ignition source
3. Fuels

As oxygen is ubiquitous in living environments, it represents the most challenging factor among the three. To prevent ignition, engineers design scenarios and potential ignition sources while devising options to eliminate possible risks. Additionally, they examine natural and abnormal phenomena that might impact a building's fire stability, such as earthquakes, forest fires, and lightning strikes. Human negligence, involving actions like smoking or the use of fire-incorporating appliances, also poses significant risks. Moreover, technological fiascos related to specific service buildings require precise distribution of fire safety appliances. Neglecting to limit fuel materials can accelerate the growth rate and smoke load of indoor fires.

Evasion and Communication

To ensure a structure's fire safety, both escape routes and communication are vital. Absence of either increases the damage potential of a fire hazard tenfold. In the event of a fire, the first step is to notify rescue services either manually or through automatic measures, providing critical information about the fire's location and size. Automatic communication systems often include sprinklers and smoke control mechanisms, complemented by manual systems like fire extinguishers.

Following the risk of irreparable damage, building inhabitants typically seek escape routes or safe places to hide if the paths are blocked. Designing buildings to facilitate safe escape during a fire is essential. Escape route risks are closely related to the presence of overwhelming heat and smoke. Generally, three basic escape methods are followed:

1. Egressing: Direct escape when an alarm sounds.
2. Seeking Refuge: Finding a safe place within a building using fire-resistant materials and structures.
3. Rescue: In situations where the first two solutions are not feasible, the building's inhabitants are rescued by responsible authorities, typically the fire department.

Suppression of Fire Hazards

Fire suppression or containment can be categorized into passive and active measures. While law inspectors specializing in insurance policies may be involved, the management of this division of Structural Fire Resistance primarily falls to engineers. It addresses both heat and smoke dangers, enabling precise suppression measurements for passive and active cases. Passive methods consider the building's envelope, subdivision, and overall structure to contain the spread of fire and smoke. However, in severe fire cases, passive measures may prove ineffective, necessitating the use of active suppression methods that require communication between inhabitants and authorities.

Passive Fire Resistance

The ability of an element to withstand the effects of fire is known as Fire Resistance, and it can be measured in various ways, including:

1. Collapse Resistance: Applicable only to loadbearing elements.
2. Fire Penetration Resistance: Maintaining the element's integrity when exposed to direct fire.
3. Excessive Heat Resistance: Providing insulation against extreme temperatures.

In certain cases, fire resistance can be enhanced through interventions, while other materials may already possess high temperature resistance, rendering intervention unnecessary. Heat resistance interventions may involve increasing the size of a composite element to prevent the overall structural performance from being affected. Additionally, insulating or dissipating the heat route by grouping elements together can bolster fire resistance.

Passive Structural Protection

Certain structural materials can withstand a specific level of fire protection, dependent on escaping needs and extinguishing time. According to Building Regulations, structural elements that provide support to specific areas, such as roofs, external walls, separating walls, gallery support roofs, and compartment walls, are required to have fire protection. Once the building's ability to withstand a fire for a specific duration is determined, the degree of fire safety for structural elements is designed accordingly.

Passive Sectioning

Dividing buildings into smaller sections using compartment walls and floors made from heat and fire-resistant materials helps block and slow down the spread of fire. This method:

1. Inhibits Rapid Fire Spread
2. Limits the Fire's Potential Danger
3. Minimizes Structural and Content Destruction

The degree of sectioning depends on factors such as the building's intended usage, the fire load within the structure, the building's height, and the availability of functioning automatic sprinklers.

Passive Enveloping Protection

Passive enveloping protection aims to enclose a structure and limit the fire's threat to adjacent buildings and people outside the affected building. Particular attention is given to the roof and outer walls, designed to prevent flaming particles from being carried away by convectional air currents and to prevent the fire from spreading to adjacent buildings. Reducing the number of windows and other openings in the outer walls helps mitigate this risk.

Active Pressure Treatment

While safe spaces are structured to prevent smoke flow, movement and opening doors can lead to smoke infiltration. This danger can be mitigated by using the lobby method of access in staircases, allowing only one door to be opened at a time. Alternatively, protecting safe spaces such as stairs and hallways with constant fresh air currents helps maintain smoke-free environments, ensuring that the pressure inside these areas is greater than that of nearby rooms. Thus, when doors are opened, smoke is prevented from flowing in due to the outward airflow.

Active Ventilation

Despite roof ventilation cleaning smoke, a layer of smoke often accumulates beneath floors and roofs, gradually increasing in depth over time. To address this, mechanical ventilators can be employed to function either manually or automatically during a fire. These systems are designed to ensure that the smoke being produced equals the smoke flowing out, preventing the smoke layer from intensifying. Additionally, smoke curtains that automatically fall in case of a fire can be used to trap smoke.

Extinguishment

Fire extinguish agents, such as water, carbon dioxide, foam, halon gas, and dry powder, can be applied manually by inhabitants or automatically by fire service personnel. One of the most well-known fire defense systems is sprinklers, which are mandatory for buildings taller than 30 meters. These sprinklers activate automatically when temperatures reach 68 degrees Celsius or can be activated manually using a switch. Their coverage typically spans a 9-square meter radius, designed to halt or at least delay the fire's progression.

In some situations where it is not safe for individuals to work near heat and fire, fire safety personnel may be required to sacrifice their lives to save others. To prevent this, engineers must provide a secure operating base for firefighters, complete with routes, stairs, lifts, and shafts for their use during emergencies.

Future Possibilities and Expectations

Given humanity's rapid technological growth, developments in various fields are anticipated. In the realm of fire safety, new inventions, such as the extinguisher ball, have emerged to aid firefighters and enhance the fire security levels of different buildings.

References

1. Purser, D. A., & Keer, R. (Eds.). (2019). "Fire Safety Engineering: Principles and Practice." CRC Press.
2. Cox, G., & McDonald, G. (2016). "Fire Properties of Polymer Composite Materials." Springer.
3. Hakiem, N. A., & Munandar, A. A. (2018). "Structural Design for Fire Safety in Buildings." Journal of Physics: Conference Series, Vol. 997, No. 1, 012090.
4. Huang, X., & Usmani, A. S. (2016). "Fire Safety Assessment of Tall Buildings: Challenges and Opportunities." International Journal of High-Rise Buildings, Vol. 5(1), 15-25.
5. Majid, M. R., Alhussan, K. S., & Alatawi, M. K. (2020). "Performance-Based Design for Fire Safety in Buildings: A Review." Journal of Engineering Research and Technology, Vol. 9(4), 609-616.
6. Babrauskas, V., Peacock, R. D., & DiNenno, P. J. (2019). "World Fire Statistics." Fire Technology, Vol. 55(2), 485-509.
7. Law, A., & Bakar, M. S. (2016). "Advancements in Fire Safety Engineering: A Review." In 2016 International Conference on Electrical, Electronic, Communication, and Control Engineering (ICEECC), IEEE, 1-5.
8. Niu, Y., Huang, X., & Fang, Y. (2018). "Analysis and Prediction of Fire-Induced Failure of Steel Structures under Actual Fire Conditions." Journal of Constructional Steel Research, Vol. 146, 37-48.