In the three makings of Lamb to the Slaughter, they all tell their story in a different way. In the text comparison to the 1979 film color, one of the main differences was that Mary had a flashback of her killing Patrick instead of her doing it in the actual time, that stood out and I think that was for a main reason, to make them different because if they didn't it would not only be boring because it's close to the text but there would be no change. It genuinely makes the scene more interesting for us to watch.
Also, they both have very different lighting throughout the story, in 1979 it's way more happy and settle in the beginning and then there's just a rude awakening and when Mary had called the cops to come and the light had all the sudden changed and everything just got very dark and shallow as she balled her eyes out talking to them. In the text, it changed lighting too but it had went on longer and she hadn't come home first she got a chance to talk to Patrick before she killed him(not in a flashback) and everything had been okay but then he told her the news of him wanting to leave her and that's when everything changes and goes dark. Lastly the characters, in 1979 Patrick didn't even get a real chance to portray himself but Mary portrayed herself to be very worried about him leaving her, as in the text Mary was the same but Patrick got a chance to express himself letting him know he no longer wants to be with her, that shows that he's just a straight up and honest person.
Then there's the text and the Hitchcock. They were layed out very alike, minimal differences. In the beginning of both the text and Hitchcock, they started out with Patrick being able to portray himself by being straight up and telling her he wants to leave. Then as the text goes on the lighting doesn't change nor does it change in Hitchcock until she kills him and as the officers come in to question her in the movie, the lighting changes to very frantic and scared but also dark because she just killed her husband. In the text although she killed her husband the lighting was more concerning as to what would happen with her baby and her. All in all each movie and the text tell the same story just in a different way to keep the readers and people watching more entertained but also to tell the story in different ways.
This essay is graded:
Satisfactory
Expert Review
The essay provides a basic analysis of the variations in the three adaptations of "Lamb to the Slaughter." It discusses differences in storytelling, lighting, and character portrayal among the text, the 1979 film, and the Hitchcock adaptation. The comparisons highlight how these elements influence the presentation of the story. While the analysis identifies some key distinctions, the points made could benefit from deeper exploration and textual examples to support the observations. The essay demonstrates an understanding of the adaptations' impact on the storytelling experience, but more thorough analysis and textual evidence would enhance the evaluation.
What can be improved
Thesis and Structure: Begin with a clear thesis that outlines the purpose of comparing adaptations. Structure the essay with a clear introduction, body paragraphs, and conclusion.
Textual Examples: Incorporate specific examples from both the text and adaptations to illustrate the differences in storytelling, lighting, and character portrayal.
Deeper Analysis: Explore the implications and effects of the differences between adaptations. How do these differences influence the audience's perception and engagement with the story?
Contextual Understanding: Provide context about the adaptations, such as their respective directors or mediums, to help the reader better understand their impact on the story.
Language and Clarity: Refine sentence structure for clarity and coherence. Avoid vague phrases like "that stood out" or "everything changes." Provide specific details to support statements.
Critical Evaluation: Move beyond describing differences to discussing why these choices might have been made and what impact they have on the narrative's themes and messages.
You can receive your plagiarism free paper on any topic in 3 hours!
To export a reference to this article please select a referencing style below
Copy to Clipboard
APA
MLA
Harvard
Vancouver
“Lamb to the Slaughter”: Comparison of the Story and the Movie.
(2020, November 26). WritingBros. Retrieved April 24, 2024, from https://writingbros.com/essay-examples/comparison-of-story-and-movie-lamb-to-the-slaughter/
““Lamb to the Slaughter”: Comparison of the Story and the Movie.” WritingBros, 26 Nov. 2020, writingbros.com/essay-examples/comparison-of-story-and-movie-lamb-to-the-slaughter/
“Lamb to the Slaughter”: Comparison of the Story and the Movie. [online].
Available at: <https://writingbros.com/essay-examples/comparison-of-story-and-movie-lamb-to-the-slaughter/> [Accessed 24 Apr. 2024].
“Lamb to the Slaughter”: Comparison of the Story and the Movie [Internet]. WritingBros.
2020 Nov 26 [cited 2024 Apr 24].
Available from: https://writingbros.com/essay-examples/comparison-of-story-and-movie-lamb-to-the-slaughter/
Read Review
