"Holes": Book and Movie Comparison

Updated
April 21, 2023
Essay grade
Satisfactory
arrow downward Read Review
Words
911 (2 pages)
Downloads
58
Download for Free
Essay grade
Satisfactory
arrow downward Read Review
"Holes": Book and Movie Comparison essay
Important: This sample is for inspiration and reference only

When thinking about the movie Holes and the book there seems to be many similarities and differences. The Holes movie by Andrew Davis and the book by Louis Sachar are based on a boy named “Stanley” that steals a pair of shoes and ends up at a juvenile detention center in a desert. This place requires the boys to dig one whole each day using their shovel as a measurement device. They must also be careful of dangerous creatures like the yellow spotted lizards while digging their holes. The Holes movie by Andrew Davis and the Holes book by Louis Sachar are a little bit different but the movie goes more in depth into the characters backerunds and the overall story. In this essay on Holes, book and movie comparison is made to define the differences between the original work and its adaptation.

Holes: comparison of the book and the movie

To begin, the major differences I noticed after reading the book and watching the movie was that Stanley in the book was made out to be an overweight School kid that was bullied. In the movie Stanley was a skinny kid and the movie didn't mention anything about hum being bullied. This makes the book and movie a bit different because in the book it seems that Stanley might not be able to stick up for himself at the camp and might nit be capable of completing his daily tasks.

No time to compare samples?
Hire a Writer

✓Full confidentiality ✓No hidden charges ✓No plagiarism

This totally changes how Stanley is perceived. Another difference I noticed was that Sam the onion man in the book was killed by Trout Walker when he was with Katherine. In this part both Katherine and Sam were on his boat when Trout came and killed Sam. In the movie, Katherine hears the steam boat Trout own heading towards Sam. Katherine is watching from her schoolhouse where she teaches and sees Trout pull up to Sams boat and kill him. This could change the way Katherine feels and her anger towards Trout. Trout is jealous of her and Sams relationship and the fact that she likes a poor black onion farmer rather than him being a rich white man. In the movie when Stanley and Zero are taken by the lawyer to leave Camp Green Lake, it starts to rain while they are standing outside. They have broke the curse of Stanleys Great Great Great Grandfather and the dry desert gets a rainfall after many years. This happens because they found the chest full go treasure that “Kissin Kate Barlow” had left behind. In the book, the rain starts while they are in the car and about to drive off.

Furthermore, some similarities I found were in both versions of the story the boys had to dig holes using their shovels as a guide. Using the shovel they would make their holes as deep as the shovel was tall and also as wide as it was tall. Camp Green Lake in both versions was a scam that the owners of the property had come up with to find the treasure of Kate Barlow. They would use the boys as slaves to do the digging each day so eventually the warden hoped one of the boys would come across the treasure or clue. Stanley also found lipstick that was stamped “KB” for Kate Barlow.

This occurred in both version and Stanley was required to turn it in as a clue. In return Stanley didn't have to finish his whole that day and got extra shower time. In both versions of the story, one early morning Stanley and Zero find a chest that is stamped with “Stanley Yelnats”. Stanley does not give up the treasure to the warden because it has his name on it. The lawyer assists by claiming that the chest rightfully belongs to Stanley. In addition, a difference toward the end of the story that is important is when Trout Walker finds Kate. In the book Kate is found in cabin on the dried up Green Lake. Trout threatens her with a gun and demands she tell him where she had buried the treasure.

In the movie, Trout finds Kate leaning up against Sams boat that had been laying in the desert. Also in the book Trout is called that because his feet smell very bad like fish. In the movie it doesn't explain why he is named Trout or how he got the name. The books says that his real name is Charles.

To conclude, when comparisng Holes book vs movie, there are many similarities and differences, but both do a great job of telling the story of Stanlet Yelnats. It seems that the movie producers purposely left out certain details when adapting the book into a film for the big screen. Some script parts of the book and movie coincide directly in the story. The movie has some parts that go into detail better than the book by going in depth and offering visuals to assist with the story itself.

References

  1. Sachar, L. (1998). Holes. Random House Children's Books.
  2. Holes (2003). Directed by Andrew Davis. United States: Walt Disney Pictures.
  3. Ryan, P. M. (2004). The production of holes: Novel, screenplay, and film. The ALAN Review, 31(2), 7-14.
  4. Beck, B. (2004). “I can fix that”: Stanleys transformation in the film adaptation of Holes. Children's Literature Association Quarterly, 29(2), 138-146.
  5. Miller, C. A. (2003). Holes (Review). Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books, 56(10), 408-409.
  6. Nelson, R. (2003). Film adaptation and the young adult audience: A study of Holes. Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 47(5), 394-404.
This essay is graded:
Satisfactory
minus plus
Expert Review
This essay undertakes a comparison between the book "Holes" by Louis Sachar and its film adaptation directed by Andrew Davis. The comparison highlights several differences and similarities between the two versions. The essay offers insights into character differences, plot variations, and storytelling choices made in the movie. It discusses aspects such as character backgrounds, key events, and narrative perspectives. However, the essay lacks a cohesive structure and fluid organization, making it somewhat challenging to follow the flow of ideas. While it covers various points of comparison, deeper analysis and more critical insights could enhance its overall depth and engagement. Additionally, refining the language and addressing grammar issues would contribute to a smoother reading experience.
minus plus
What can be improved
Structured Analysis: Organize the essay with clear headings for differences and similarities, creating distinct sections for each point. Supporting Examples: Provide specific examples from the book and movie to illustrate differences and similarities, enhancing the credibility of the comparison. Logical Flow: Use transitional phrases to guide readers through the essay and improve the coherence of ideas. Deeper Analysis: Offer more critical insights into the reasons behind the differences and the impact on the narrative and audience experience. Grammar and Language: Revise sentence structures and correct grammar issues to enhance readability and clarity.
You can receive your plagiarism free paper on any topic in 3 hours!

*minimum deadline

Cite this Essay

To export a reference to this article please select a referencing style below

Copy to Clipboard
“Holes”: Book and Movie Comparison. (2023, April 21). WritingBros. Retrieved March 28, 2024, from https://writingbros.com/essay-examples/similarities-and-differences-between-the-holes-movie-adaptation-and-the-original-book/
““Holes”: Book and Movie Comparison.” WritingBros, 21 Apr. 2023, writingbros.com/essay-examples/similarities-and-differences-between-the-holes-movie-adaptation-and-the-original-book/
“Holes”: Book and Movie Comparison. [online]. Available at: <https://writingbros.com/essay-examples/similarities-and-differences-between-the-holes-movie-adaptation-and-the-original-book/> [Accessed 28 Mar. 2024].
“Holes”: Book and Movie Comparison [Internet]. WritingBros. 2023 Apr 21 [cited 2024 Mar 28]. Available from: https://writingbros.com/essay-examples/similarities-and-differences-between-the-holes-movie-adaptation-and-the-original-book/
Copy to Clipboard
"Holes": Book and Movie Comparison essay

Need writing help?

You can always rely on us no matter what type of paper you need

Order My Paper

*No hidden charges

/